Five buy-vs-lease scenarios

These rows come from the same function the calculator runs, so you can match your own quote against a known case. The break-even column is the useful one: it tells you how much headroom your lease quote has before buying wins.

PriceTermResaleBuy netLease quoteLease netCheaperBreak-even
$50,0005 yr20%$40,795$900$44,840Buy$811/mo
$50,0005 yr20%$40,795$1,050$51,680Buy$811/mo
$30,0003 yr10%$20,520$850$23,256Buy$750/mo
$120,0007 yr25%$101,347$1,900$130,416Buy$1,445/mo
$85,0005 yr45%$55,164$1,250$57,000Buy$1,210/mo

The last row is the case that surprises people: equipment holding 45% of its value after five years narrows the gap sharply. A lease quoted at $1,250 against a $1,210 break-even is only $40 a month from flipping — well inside the negotiating range of a single phone call.

Why a loan and a lease cannot be compared by monthly payment

Buy net = total loan paid − Section 179 shield − after-tax resale value
You own the asset, so its residual value is a real credit against the cost.
Lease net = (payments × months + down) × (1 − tax rate)
Payments are deductible; you walk away owning nothing.

Most comparisons stop at the monthly figure. A $900 lease on a $50,000 machine looks cheaper than a $923 loan payment, but the buyer still owns something worth $10,000 at the end. Comparing payments alone systematically tilts the answer toward leasing.

What Section 179 does to the comparison

Section 179 lets a business deduct the full price of qualifying equipment in the year it is placed in service, up to the annual limit ($1,160,000 for 2025-2026, phasing out above $2,890,000 of annual purchases). On a $50,000 machine at a 24% marginal rate that is a $12,000 tax reduction — enough to swing a close comparison. Leased equipment does not qualify for Section 179, but the payments are deductible as ordinary expense, producing a similar but slower benefit.

Set the Section 179 limit to 0 if you have already used the deduction this year or the property is excluded. Real estate, property used outside the US, and equipment bought from a related party do not qualify.

The residual assumption is the whole ballgame

Every comparison hinges on what the equipment is worth at the end of the term. Construction and agricultural equipment tends to hold value; specialized machinery in a narrow niche can lose it fast. Run the calculator at two or three residual assumptions — the answer often flips between 20% and 45%.

When leasing genuinely wins

Leasing beats buying in three specific situations, and only three. First, when the equipment depreciates faster than the lease residual assumes — the lessor ate the loss instead of you. Second, when you need the equipment for a term shorter than its useful life, so owning the tail end is wasted capital. Third, when cash preservation matters more than total cost: a lease usually needs one or two payments upfront versus a 10-20% down payment on a loan.

Outside those cases the arithmetic tends to favor buying, because the lender needs to earn a return on the full asset while the lessor needs to earn a return on the same asset plus a margin for absorbing the residual risk. The calculator shows you exactly how much margin you are paying for that transfer of risk.

The questions to ask before signing

Ask what the buyout option costs at the end of the lease. A lease with a below-market buyout is effectively a loan with a balloon; a lease with an above-market buyout means you are renting. Ask whether the lease is a true lease or a $1 buyout lease for tax purposes — the classification changes whether payments are deductible or whether you treat it as a purchase and take Section 179 instead.

Ask what happens if you terminate early. Equipment leases are typically non-cancelable, and early termination usually means paying the remaining payments, sometimes discounted to present value. If your business outlook is uncertain over the term, that clause matters more than the monthly number.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to lease or buy equipment for a small business? ▾
It depends on residual value and cash position, not the monthly payment. Buying wins when the equipment holds value and you can use Section 179; leasing wins for short-term needs or when preserving cash matters more than total cost. Compare your actual quote against the break-even lease figure this calculator produces.
Can I use Section 179 on leased equipment? ▾
No. Section 179 applies to purchased property only. Lease payments are instead deducted as an ordinary business expense each year, which spreads the tax benefit across the term rather than concentrating it in year one.
What is the Section 179 limit for 2026? ▾
$1,160,000 of qualifying equipment, with the deduction phasing out dollar-for-dollar above $2,890,000 of total equipment purchases in the year. These figures are indexed annually, so confirm the current-year amount before filing.
Does a lease payment include sales tax? ▾
Often yes — many states tax lease payments monthly even when they exempt the initial purchase. That adds roughly 6-9% to the quoted payment depending on your state, and it is deductible alongside the payment.
What happens if I want to end an equipment lease early? ▾
Most equipment leases are non-cancelable and early termination requires paying the remaining payments, sometimes discounted to present value. Some leases offer an early buyout schedule that declines over time. Read that clause before signing — it is usually the most expensive term in the contract.
⚠️ Important note

This calculator models federal tax treatment only. State tax, sales tax on lease payments, and lease-specific fees are excluded. Section 179 limits are indexed annually and change with legislation; verify the current-year figure. The result is a planning comparison, not a tax opinion — confirm the treatment with your accountant before committing.