📈 Purchase & Appraisal

💵 Cash Needed to Close

Planned Down Payment$40,000
Amount You Must Finance$360,000
Appraisal Shortfall$10,000
LTV on Appraised Value92.31%
Loan Lender Will Fund$370,500
EXTRA CASH REQUIRED$0
Total Cash at Closing$40,000
Enter your terms to see whether a low appraisal forces extra cash.

Extra cash shown excludes closing costs (typically 2โ€“5% of the loan) and prepaid escrow items.

๐Ÿ“Š Worked Examples

Each row is computed by this page's own formula at a 95% maximum LTV, so the numbers match what the calculator returns for those inputs.

Contract PriceDownAppraisedShortfallLTV on AppraisalLoan FundedExtra CashTotal Cash
$400,00010%$400,000$090.00%$360,000$0$40,000
$400,00010%$390,000$10,00092.31%$360,000$0$40,000
$500,00020%$470,000$30,00085.11%$400,000$0$100,000
$600,00010%$550,000$50,00098.18%$522,500$17,500$77,500
$350,0005%$340,000$10,00097.79%$323,000$9,500$27,000

What the table shows

The first row is the clean case: appraisal equals price, so the planned 10% down payment stands and no extra cash is needed. The second row is the most common real-world surprise โ€” a 2.5% low appraisal on a 10%-down purchase, which pushes LTV on the appraised value from 90% to 92.31%. At a 95% cap the loan still covers the need, so the buyer escapes unharmed.

Row four is where it bites. A $600,000 price with only 10% down and a $550,000 appraisal means you need $540,000 but the cap is $522,500 โ€” an $17,500 shortfall on top of a $60,000 down payment. That is the case worth modelling before you waive an appraisal contingency.

Why the LTV column matters more than the shortfall

A $10,000 appraisal gap is painless on a 20%-down purchase and painful on a 5%-down purchase, because the gap is measured against the lender's LTV headroom. The shortfall number alone tells you the price difference; the LTV column tells you whether the lender will actually refuse to fund it.

๐Ÿ“– How to Use This Calculator

  1. Enter the contract price โ€” the number on your purchase agreement, not the list price.
  2. Enter your planned down payment percentage as a share of that contract price. This is what you intend to pay, not what the lender ends up requiring.
  3. Enter the appraised value. If the appraisal has not happened yet, run scenarios at 95%, 97% and 100% of the contract price to see your exposure range.
  4. Pick the lender's maximum LTV. Conventional first-time buyer programs go to 97%; standard conventional to 95%; investment properties are typically capped at 85โ€“90%; 80% avoids mortgage insurance entirely.
  5. Read the "Extra Cash Required" row. That is the additional money you need beyond your planned down payment, before closing costs.

How the math works

Max Loan = Appraised Value ร— Max LTV
The most the lender will fund, regardless of contract price
Extra Cash = (Price โˆ’ Down Payment) โˆ’ Max Loan
Floored at zero โ€” if the cap already covers the need, nothing extra is required

Planning around appraisal risk

  • Check recent comps before you offer. Your agent can pull the last 90 days of closed sales in the same subdivision. If your offer is above all of them, appraisal risk is real.
  • Know your loan program's flexibility. VA allows financing the contract price above appraised value when the seller agrees; FHA does not.
  • Do not drain reserves to cover a gap. Lenders verify reserves after closing, and a depleted account can itself kill the loan.
  • Keep the contingency unless you can afford the gap. Waiving it is a cash commitment, not a negotiating gesture.

๐Ÿ“‰ Why an appraisal can blow a hole in your down payment

Lenders do not lend against the price you agreed to pay โ€” they lend against the value a licensed appraiser puts on the property. If the appraiser comes in below the contract price, the lender treats the difference as money you must supply yourself. Nothing about the contract changes: you still owe the seller the full price, but the bank will only finance the appraised value at your agreed loan-to-value.

Consider a $400,000 purchase with 10% down. You plan to borrow $360,000. If the appraisal lands at $390,000, a 90% LTV loan caps out at $351,000 โ€” a $9,000 shortfall you must cover in cash at closing, on top of your $40,000 down payment. Nationally, roughly 8โ€“10% of purchase appraisals come in below contract price, and the rate is higher in fast-appreciating markets where comparable sales lag the current market.

How lenders actually apply the cap

Conventional loans typically allow up to 97% LTV for first-time buyers and 95% generally, but only on the appraised value. FHA loans are stricter about this because the appraisal determines the maximum insurable mortgage. VA loans are the most forgiving โ€” the VA will finance the contract price even when the appraisal is lower, provided the buyer and seller agree, which is why VA buyers sometimes win bidding wars on low appraisals.

The appraisal contingency is your real protection

Most standard purchase contracts include an appraisal contingency: if the home appraises below the contract price, you can renegotiate, walk away with your earnest money, or cover the gap. Waiving that contingency โ€” common in competitive 2025โ€“2026 markets โ€” means committing to cover any shortfall out of pocket. This calculator tells you the size of the check you would need to write if you waive it.

Three ways to handle a low appraisal

โ“ Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if the appraisal comes in lower than the offer?โ–พ
The lender will only finance based on the appraised value at your agreed LTV. The difference between the contract price and the appraised value becomes additional cash you must bring to closing, unless you renegotiate the price with the seller or the loan program explicitly permits financing the contract price.
Can I appeal a low appraisal?โ–พ
Yes. You can request a reconsideration of value (ROV) through your lender, supplying better comparable sales the appraiser missed โ€” typically recent closed sales in the same subdivision with similar square footage and condition. Success rates are modest, generally 20โ€“30%, and deadlines are short, so act within a few days.
Does a low appraisal affect my property taxes?โ–พ
Not directly โ€” your tax assessment is set by the county, not your lender's appraiser, and the two use different methods and effective dates. But a low appraisal is useful evidence if you plan to appeal your assessment, because it is an independent professional opinion of value you can submit with the appeal.
How much cash should I have beyond the down payment?โ–พ
Plan for closing costs of 2โ€“5% of the loan amount, plus at least three to six months of mortgage payments in reserves. If there is meaningful appraisal risk โ€” a competitive market, a unique property, few comparable sales โ€” add the potential gap to that reserve so a low appraisal does not force you to walk away.
Do I lose my earnest money if I walk away over a low appraisal?โ–พ
Usually not, if your contract has an active appraisal contingency and you exercise it within the stated window. If you waived the contingency, the seller may keep the deposit. That is why waiving it is effectively a promise to cover any appraisal shortfall in cash.
Will a second appraisal help?โ–พ
Sometimes, but lenders rarely order one just because you dislike the first result, and you typically cannot choose the appraiser. A second appraisal is most useful when the first is demonstrably flawed โ€” wrong square footage, missed updates, or comparables outside the subject's market area.

โš ๏ธ Important: This calculator models the lender's LTV cap using a single maximum-LTV assumption. Real programs vary by loan type, credit score, occupancy and lender overlays โ€” FHA, VA, USDA and conventional each treat appraised value differently. Confirm your program's rules and your lender's actual maximum LTV before relying on any number here. This is an educational estimate, not a loan commitment or appraisal.