Replacement cost across six roles

Every row is produced by the same function the calculator runs. Notice how tightly the cost tracks salary — roughly half a year of pay per departure, which is why turnover compounds so quickly in high-volume roles.

Role salaryMonths openCost per departure% of salaryAnnual (1 exit)
$60,0002.5$33,35856%$33,358
$45,0001.5$23,40152%$23,401
$85,0003$48,73957%$48,739
$120,0004$73,18561%$73,185
$35,0001.0$17,60350%$17,603
$75,0002$40,23554%$40,235

Fill this out for a team rather than a role and the scale becomes uncomfortable: a 60-person company with 15% turnover replaces nine people a year. At an average $33,000 per departure that is roughly $300,000 — usually several times the annual budget of the retention program nobody funded.

The five cost buckets that make up a departure

cost = separation + vacancy + recruiting + onboarding + ramp-up
Each bucket is separately arguable; together they are rarely below half a year of salary.

Separation is the smallest bucket — final payouts, COBRA administration, exit processing. Most companies track this one and therefore underestimate turnover dramatically.

Vacancy is the work that does not get done while the seat is open, net of what colleagues absorb. If a role is open for 2.5 months and colleagues cover roughly two-thirds of the load, you lose about a third of the role's output times 2.5 months. This is usually the largest single bucket and the one nobody puts in the spreadsheet.

Recruiting covers job postings, agency fees, and internal recruiter time. Agency placements commonly run 20-25% of first-year salary; a strong inbound pipeline can bring it under 10%.

Onboarding is paid hours that produce no output yet — the new hire's orientation plus the mentor's time away from their own work.

Ramp-up is the productivity gap after training but before full speed. A role that reaches full output in 3 months at an average of 50% productivity loses 1.5 months of output.

Why the number matters more for small teams

A 200-person company losing ten people a year feels the cost as a budget line. A 12-person company losing two people loses 17% of its capacity at once — the vacancy cost is multiplied because colleagues genuinely cannot absorb the work, and the founder picks up the overflow. The calculator's "months open" field is where that difference shows up.

Reading the number honestly

The calculator produces a defensible estimate, not an audited figure. Two inputs deserve scepticism. The first is "months open" — managers routinely underestimate it because they remember the hiring sprint, not the six weeks before the requisition was approved. The second is the coverage assumption baked into the vacancy figure: on a team of three, colleagues cannot absorb two-thirds of a missing role, so the real vacancy cost is closer to the full salary.

Run it twice, once with conservative inputs and once with harsh ones, and use the midpoint. The purpose is not precision — it is to put a number next to a decision that is usually argued only in qualitative terms. A retention raise that costs $6,000 against a $33,000 replacement cost is an easy call once both numbers are on the same page.

Which retention levers actually move the number

The levers that matter most are the two biggest buckets. Vacancy cost falls when you keep a warm pipeline — a role filled in four weeks instead of ten saves about 60% of the vacancy figure. Ramp-up cost falls with structured onboarding: a new hire reaching full productivity in two months instead of three saves a full month of loaded salary, and the effect is larger on complex roles where ramps run six months or longer.

Recruiting cost falls with referral programs, which typically produce hires at a fraction of agency fees. Separation and onboarding are largely fixed. If you are choosing where to spend a retention budget, the vacancy and ramp buckets have the most room to move, and both respond to planning rather than to compensation.

Frequently asked questions

What is the average cost to replace an employee? ▾
Published estimates range from 30% to 200% of annual salary depending on seniority. Hourly and entry-level roles cluster near 30-50%, professional roles near 50-100%, and specialised or executive roles well above 100%. This calculator lands in the 50-60% range for a typical professional role with a two-to-three month vacancy.
Does turnover cost include the lost productivity of coworkers? ▾
It should, and most simple formulas omit it. When a seat is open, colleagues absorb part of the work and their own output suffers. This calculator captures it inside the vacancy bucket by applying a coverage-gap percentage rather than charging the full salary as a loss.
How is the vacancy cost calculated? ▾
Salary divided by twelve, multiplied by months open, multiplied by the benefits load, then multiplied by a coverage-gap factor. The gap factor defaults to 35%, meaning colleagues and managers absorb about two-thirds of the missing output. On small teams that gap is larger and the factor should be raised.
What turnover rate is considered healthy? ▾
Overall voluntary turnover around 10-15% per year is typical for most industries. Retail and hospitality run far higher, often 40-60%. Technology and professional services sit nearer 13-20%. Compare within your industry rather than against a universal benchmark — a 10% rate in hospitality is exceptional, and the same rate in a stable professional firm is elevated.
Is it cheaper to retain an employee or replace them? ▾
Almost always cheaper to retain, except where the role itself is wrong. A retention increase of 10% of salary costs roughly $6,000 on a $60,000 role, against a replacement cost near $33,000. The exception is a genuinely underperforming employee: retaining the wrong person carries its own cost that this calculator does not model.
⚠️ Important note

This calculator estimates replacement cost from your inputs; it is not an accounting figure. Vacancy and ramp-up costs depend on assumptions about how much work colleagues absorb, which vary widely by team size and role type. Benefits load and recruiting costs differ by industry and region. Use the result to frame a retention decision, not as a line item for financial statements.