A 1.5% late fee sounds like protection. Price it against carrying cost, collection effort and write-off risk and it often recovers only a fraction of what a slow payer actually costs.
Each row is produced by the same function the calculator runs. The first six show a late charge comfortably covering the cost of waiting. The last row shows what happens when collection effort and write-off risk enter the picture.
| Invoice | Days late | Charged | % of invoice | Your cost | Net |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | 15 | $200 | 2.0% | $37 | $163 |
| $10,000 | 60 | $350 | 3.5% | $148 | $202 |
| $25,000 | 45 | $1,062 | 4.2% | $277 | $785 |
| $5,000 | 90 | $225 | 4.5% | $111 | $114 |
| $100,000 | 30 | $1,750 | 1.8% | $740 | $1,010 |
| $12,000 | 120 | $660 | 5.5% | $355 | $305 |
| $25,000 | 45 | $1,062 | 4.2% | $2,727 (incl. effort + risk) | $-1,665 |
The last row is the one to sit with. A $25,000 invoice 45 days late collects $1,062 in fees and interest — but $1,200 of collection effort plus a 5% write-off probability turns that into a $1,665 net loss. The late fee was never the protection it looked like.
Carrying cost is usually modest. At a 9% cost of capital, $25,000 outstanding for 45 extra days ties up about $277 of financing. That is why a 1.5% monthly charge looks generous — on a 45-day delay it bills $562, twice the carrying cost.
The charge only works while the customer eventually pays. Once an invoice crosses roughly 90 days, the probability of partial or total non-payment rises steeply, and the collection effort — calls, statements, a collections agency taking 25-50% — starts to outweigh the fee. At that point the late charge is a rounding error against a five-figure exposure.
A 1.5% monthly rate annualises to about 20% simple interest, which is well inside most state usury limits for commercial credit. Some states cap commercial late charges, and a few require the rate to be stated in the contract before it can be enforced — an unenforceable clause collects nothing.
Prevention beats penalty. Shortening terms from net-30 to net-15 on new customers, requiring a deposit on the first order, or offering a 2% discount for payment within ten days all change behaviour before the invoice ages. A late fee is what you charge after the relationship has already gone wrong.
Payment terms are a promise, not a mechanism. A customer who pays at day 45 on net-30 terms has borrowed your money interest-free for two weeks, and there is usually no consequence because the supplier wants to keep the account. Over a year, a customer on net-30 who consistently pays at day 60 is effectively financed by you for two months of every invoice cycle.
Quantify it once and the scale becomes visible. A customer invoicing $20,000 a month with 30 extra days on every payment is carrying a $20,000 loan from you at zero interest. Apply your own cost of capital — or the rate on your line of credit — and the annual cost of that arrangement appears. That number, not the late fee, is the argument for renegotiating terms.
State it in the contract, not only on the invoice. A late charge that appears for the first time on a past-due statement is often unenforceable, because the customer never agreed to it. Put the rate, the trigger day, and the compounding convention in the master services agreement and reference it on every invoice.
Keep the rate defensible. Commercial late charges commonly run 1% to 1.5% per month; a few states cap them, and a rate that reads as punitive invites a dispute that costs more than the fee. Pair the charge with a softer tool — a call at day 35, a hold on new orders at day 60 — so the fee is one part of a collection sequence rather than the whole strategy.
This calculator models the economics of a late charge and is not legal advice. Commercial late-fee and interest rules vary by state, and a rate not stated in your contract may be unenforceable. Write-off probability and collection effort are estimates you supply — the result is only as good as those inputs. Consult counsel before setting terms.