Your quoted price per gallon or per therm says almost nothing about what winter costs. This converts every fuel to a cost per million BTU delivered into the room — so a cheap propane quote and an expensive heat pump can finally be compared.
The only column that can be compared across rows is cost per million BTU. Annual cost differs because each house burns a different amount of fuel — a big house with a cheap fuel can cost more than a small house with an expensive one.
| Scenario | Fuel used | Annual cost | Cost per million BTU |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural gas, 800 therms @ $1.10, 90% furnace | 800 therm | $880 | $12 |
| Heating oil, 600 gal @ $4.10, 85% boiler | 600 gal | $2,460 | $35 |
| Propane, 900 gal @ $2.60, 92% furnace | 900 gal | $2,340 | $31 |
| Electric resistance, 9000 kWh @ $0.17, 100% | 9,000 kWh | $1,530 | $50 |
| Heat pump, 6000 kWh @ $0.17, COP 300% | 6,000 kWh | $1,020 | $17 |
The heat pump row is the interesting one. It uses the same $0.17 per kWh as the resistance row but delivers three times the heat per kWh, so its cost per million BTU is roughly a third. That gap — not the sticker price of the equipment — is what decides whether a heat pump pays for itself.
Here every fuel is asked to deliver exactly 60 million BTU into the house, which is roughly a 1,500 sq ft home in a 5,000 HDD climate. Prices are typical 2026 US averages; substitute yours.
| Fuel | Units needed for 60 MMBtu | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| Natural gas | 643 therm | $707 |
| Heating oil | 509 gal | $2,087 |
| Propane | 713 gal | $1,853 |
| Electric resistance | 17,584 kWh | $2,989 |
| Heat pump (COP 3.0) | 5,861 kWh | $996 |
These figures use delivered heat, so the furnace efficiency is already inside the unit count — an 85% oil boiler needs more gallons than the raw BTU math suggests. If you are quoted a price per gallon without an efficiency figure, you are comparing the wrong number.
A gallon of heating oil contains about 138,690 BTU. A gallon of propane contains about 91,500. A therm of natural gas contains about 103,700. A kilowatt-hour of electricity contains 3,412 BTU no matter how it was generated. Because the units differ, the price per unit is not comparable — you have to normalise to BTU before the numbers mean anything.
An old atmospheric gas boiler at 70% AFUE throws away 30 cents of every dollar up the flue. A modern condensing furnace at 96% keeps almost all of it. Replacing a 70% boiler with a 96% furnace cuts the gas bill by roughly 27% with no change in comfort — a bigger gain than most people get from shopping around for a cheaper supplier.
Heat pumps break the pattern because their "efficiency" exceeds 100%. A unit with a seasonal COP of 3.0 moves three units of heat for every unit of electricity, which is why the number behaves more like 300% in the efficiency field. Do not enter the nameplate HSPF rating directly — convert it (roughly HSPF ÷ 3.412 = COP) or use the manufacturer's seasonal COP.
This tool prices heat. It does not price the equipment, the install, the ductwork, or the electrical panel upgrade a heat pump may require. A heat pump that costs $6,000 more to install but saves $600 a year has a ten-year payback before any incentive — and many states and utilities now cover a large share of that gap. Run the annual-cost number first, then subtract incentives from the capital cost separately.
Step 1 — get your real usage. Pull twelve months of bills, not one. Heating usage is heavily seasonal, and a single January bill extrapolated across a year overstates everything.
Step 2 — find your actual delivered price. Use the total bill divided by total units, including delivery charges, taxes and fees. The commodity price on the front page of the bill is not what you pay.
Step 3 — enter seasonal efficiency, not peak efficiency. A furnace rated 96% AFUE may run at 91% in a mild climate where it short-cycles. Use the AFUE for furnaces and boilers; use seasonal COP for heat pumps.
Step 4 — compare in cost per million BTU, then decide. If two fuels land within about 10% of each other, the decision is about capital cost and comfort, not operating cost. Only a gap wider than that justifies switching equipment.
This calculator prices energy, not equipment. It does not include installation, maintenance, ductwork, electrical upgrades, or available rebates and tax credits, all of which can change a fuel-switching decision substantially. Fuel prices vary by region and season and should be taken from your own bills rather than national averages.